Gender and Inclusive Justice Case: Sabina Damai vs. Government of Nepal & Others, NKP (2068), Р. 247, DN: 8557
Case: Mandamus
Plaintiff: Sabina Damai et.al.
Defendant: Government of Nepal, Office of the PM and Council of Ministers
Decision Number: 8557
The case is relating to citizenship through a Nepali mother, equality in citizenship rights, and whether an unknown father can prevent a person from obtaining citizenship.
Facts:
Sabina Damai, an 18 year old woman from Dolakha, was born to Gangamaya Damai, a Nepali citizen by descent. Sabina’s father was unknown, and neither she nor her mother knew his identity or address.
Sabina completed all the required procedures and submitted the necessary documents to obtain Nepali citizenship through her mother. She also appeared before the concerned authorities for verification.
However, the Chief District Officer of Dolakha refused to issue her citizenship certificate, stating that her father’s identity and address had not been disclosed. Her application was returned orally on this ground.
As a result, Sabina faced difficulties proving her legal identity and accessing important rights and services, including employment, property ownership, and political participation.
The case was also filed as a public interest petition because other children of Nepali mothers were reportedly facing similar obstacles.
The petition challenged the practice of requiring information about the father when a person applies for citizenship through a Nepali mother. It relied on the constitutional provisions on citizenship and equality, the Nepal Citizenship Act, 2006, the Citizenship Rules, 2006, and relevant international human rights instruments.
Plaintiff’s Claims:
The petitioners claimed that Sabina was entitled to citizenship through her Nepali mother and that the identity or address of her father was not a legal requirement. They argued that refusing her citizenship violated her rights to citizenship, identity and equality and discriminated against children seeking citizenship through their mothers.
Defendants’ Arguments:
The respondents argued that citizenship could be issued only after the required legal procedure and verification had been completed. The District Administration Office maintained that Sabina’s father’s details had not been established and that she had not accepted a certificate describing her parental information in the manner permitted by law. They also argued that other legal remedies were available and sought dismissal of the petition.
Legal Issues:
- Whether a person born in Nepal to a Nepali mother could obtain citizenship through the mother’s name?
- Whether the identity or address of the father was necessary for issuing citizenship through the mother?
- Whether refusing citizenship because the father was unknown violated the right to equality and identity?
- Whether the Court could issue directions to prevent similar denial of citizenship to others?
Different Court Decisions:
Administrative Decision:
The Chief District Officer of Dolakha refused to issue Sabina’s citizenship certificate because her father’s identity and address were unknown.
Supreme Court:
The Supreme Court allowed the petition, holding that the constitutional expression “father or mother” did not require information about both parents. Citizenship through a Nepali mother could not be denied merely because the father’s identity was unknown.
The Court held that refusing Sabina’s citizenship on this ground was discriminatory and that patriarchal practices could not override constitutional rights.
It ordered the District Administration Office to issue Sabina’s citizenship certificate through her mother’s name.
The Court also directed the Home Ministry to instruct Chief District Officers not to deny citizenship to children of Nepali mothers merely because their fathers were unknown. It further directed the Government to address discriminatory practices and raise awareness about women’s equal citizenship rights.
Principles Established:
1. Citizenship can be obtained through either a Nepali father or mother, as provided by law.
2. An unknown father cannot be a reason to deny citizenship through a Nepali mother.
3. Citizenship authorities must apply the law without gender discrimination.
4. Patriarchal practices cannot override constitutional rights and the right to legal identity.





