Sat 21 November, 2026

Gender and Inclusive Justice Case: Premilal Chaudhary vs. Office of Prime Minister, Council of Minister, NKP (8th Semester, New Syllabus)

Gender and Inclusive Justice Case: Premilal Chaudhary vs. Office of Prime Minister, Council of Minister, NKP 2080 B.S, No. 7, DN: 11125


Case:
Ceriorari
Plaintiff: Premilal Chaudhary
Defendant: Office of Prime Minister, Council of Minister
Decision Number: 11125


This case relates to reservation in employment, the rights of the Tharu community, and the State’s duty to implement proportional inclusion under the Constitution.


Facts of the Case:
The petitioners were members and representatives of the Tharu community. One of the petitioners was authorised by the Tharu Welfare Association, an organisation working for the rights and interests of the Tharu community.

The Constitution recognises the right of socially and economically backward groups, including the Tharu community, to participate in state bodies on the basis of proportional inclusion. The Constitution also requires laws to be made for the implementation of fundamental rights.

On 14 November 2021, Rastriya Banijya Bank published vacancy notices for several posts. The notices created inclusive categories for women, Indigenous Nationalities, Madhesi, Dalit, persons with disabilities and the backward region. They did not create a separate Tharu category.

The petitioners approached the Tharu Commission. The Commission decided that the concerned authorities should issue a new advertisement including a Tharu category. The vacancy process was not cancelled, and the petitioners then filed a writ petition before the Supreme Court.


Petitioners’ Claim:
The petitioners said that the bank’s vacancy notices ignored the Tharu community’s constitutional right to proportional inclusion and employment. They asked the Court to cancel the notices and order a fresh advertisement with a separate Tharu reservation category. They also asked the Court to ensure the implementation of an earlier Supreme Court order concerning Tharu reservation.


Government and Bank’s Argument:
The Government argued that Tharu people were already included under the Indigenous Nationalities category. It said that the exact percentage and method of reservation had to be fixed by legislation and could not be created only on the basis of population figures.

The bank argued that its employee regulations already provided inclusive categories. It said that Tharu applicants could compete under the Indigenous Nationalities category. It also argued that cancelling the advertisements would interfere with the bank’s recruitment process.


Legal Issues:

  1. Whether the Tharu community is entitled to a separate reservation category under the Constitution?
  2. Whether reservation can be fixed only on the basis of the population of a community?
  3. Whether the Government had failed to make laws necessary to implement the constitutional right to proportional inclusion?
  4. Whether the bank’s vacancy notices should be cancelled for not creating a separate Tharu category?

 

Decisions of the court:
Supreme Court:
Supreme Court held that the Tharu community is a separate group recognised by the Constitution and that the State had delayed implementing its right to proportional inclusion.

However, the Court did not fix a specific reservation percentage. It said that the groups entitled to reservation, their percentages and eligibility criteria must be clearly defined by law.

The Court directed the Government to make the necessary laws within nine months. It also said that reservation must be based on actual social, cultural and economic backwardness, not population alone.

The Court refused to cancel the existing bank advertisements because the petitioners had not applied for those posts and some recruitment processes were already completed.

However, the Government was directed to provide the missed reservation opportunities in future recruitment, including the posts lost since fiscal year 2079/80.

The writ petition was partly allowed. No criminal punishment was involved, as this was a constitutional case.


Principle Established:
1. Reservation cannot be based only on population size. The State must also consider the actual social, cultural and economic backwardness of the concerned community.
2. The percentage and eligibility criteria for reservation must be clearly defined by law, considering the constitutional recognition of groups such as the Tharu community.
3. Reservation policies must have clear objectives, time limits, proper monitoring and periodic review to ensure they achieve their intended purpose.
4. The State cannot indefinitely delay the implementation of constitutional rights, including the right to inclusive participation.

How did this news make you feel?
0
0
0
0
0
0

About Author

Picture of Entertain Lawyers

Entertain Lawyers

Entertain Lawyers is Nepal’s trusted legal news platform, dedicated to delivering unbiased legal updates, court news, and informative content for legal professionals and the general public.
Picture of Entertain Lawyers

Entertain Lawyers

Entertain Lawyers is Nepal’s trusted legal news platform, dedicated to delivering unbiased legal updates, court news, and informative content for legal professionals and the general public.

Related Post

error: Content is protected !!