Gender and Inclusive Justice Case: Adhip Pokhrel vs. Minister of Home Affair, Department of Immigration, NKP 2080 B.S, No. 5, DN: 11097
Case: Certiorari and mandamus
Plaintiff: Adhip Pokhrel
Defendant: Minister of Home Affair, Department of Immigration et.al
Decision Number: 11097
This case relates to the right of a foreign same sex spouse of a Nepali citizen to obtain a non tourist spouse visa and the protection of the rights of sexual and gender minorities.
Facts of the Case:
Adhip Pokharel is a Nepali citizen, while Tobias Volz is a German citizen. Both are gay men belonging to the sexual and gender minority community.
They met in Nepal and married under German law on 19 October 2018. Their marriage was officially registered in Germany, and they received an authenticated marriage certificate.
After the marriage, Tobias applied for a non tourist spouse visa to live in Nepal. However, the Department of Immigration asked for a marriage certificate registered in Nepal.
When Adhip approached the local ward office, he was informed that Nepal had no procedure for registering same sex marriages. Despite submitting their German marriage certificate and referring to an earlier Supreme Court order, Tobias was again denied the visa verbally.
The couple then filed a writ petition before the Supreme Court, seeking a spouse visa for Tobias and removal of legal barriers faced by same sex couples and other sexual and gender minorities.
Petitioners’ Claim:
The petitioners said that they were legally married under German law and had submitted an official marriage certificate. They argued that a foreign same sex spouse of a Nepali citizen should receive the same non tourist spouse visa as other spouses. They also asked the Court to protect their rights to equality, identity, dignity and family life.
Government’s Argument:
The Department of Immigration said that Tobias had not properly applied through the online system or had not submitted all required documents. It stated that an applicant must provide the documents required by immigration law, including proof of marriage. It argued that the visa application could be considered after the required documents were submitted and verified.
Legal Issues:
- Whether Tobias was entitled to a non tourist spouse visa as the foreign spouse of a Nepali citizen?
- Whether a marriage legally registered in a foreign country could be considered for the visa application?
- Whether refusing or delaying the visa because the same sex marriage was not registered in Nepal amounted to discrimination?
- Whether the words “husband” and “wife” in immigration forms and laws excluded same sex couples?
Decision of the different courts:
Supreme Court:
Supreme Court held that a same sex marriage legally registered in Germany could not be rejected simply because it was not registered in Nepal. The authenticated foreign marriage certificate was sufficient to establish the marriage.
The Court ruled that a foreign same sex spouse of a Nepali citizen cannot be denied a non tourist visa because of their sexual orientation or gender identity. Such denial would violate the rights to equality and dignity.
The Court clarified that the Nepali spouse’s citizenship certificate, official marriage certificate and identification documents of both spouses were sufficient for visa consideration.
The Court also directed the Government to amend immigration forms and procedures so that terms like “husband” and “wife” do not prevent same sex couples from obtaining spouse visas.
The writ petition was allowed. No criminal punishment was involved, as this was a constitutional rights case.
Principle Established:
1. Foreign same sex spouses of Nepali citizens must receive equal treatment in visa matters. Their foreign marriage certificates cannot be rejected simply because the marriage was not registered in Nepal.
2. Immigration authorities cannot deny visas based on a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity.
3. Terms like “husband” and “wife” must be interpreted in a way that includes same sex couples.
4. The State must protect the dignity and equal rights of sexual and gender minorities. Immigration rules and forms must not create barriers for same sex couples.





