Sat 21 November, 2026

Gender and Inclusive Justice Case: Prachi Rayamajhi vs. Vashker Singh Karki, NKP (8th Semester, New Syllabus)

Gender and Inclusive Justice Case: Prachi Rayamajhi vs. Vashker Singh Karki, NKP 2079 B.S No. 9, DN: 10936

Case: Partition of Property
Plaintiff: Prachi Rayamajhi
Defendant: Vashker Singh Karki
Decision Number: 10936

This case relates to a minor child’s right to inherit property and the mother’s right to manage that property after the parents’ divorce.


Facts of the Case:
Sarahana Karki was the minor daughter of Bhaskar Singh Karki and Prachi Rayamajhi. Her parents had divorced, and she was living with her mother. Sarahana was nine years old when the case was filed.

In an earlier divorce and partition case, Prachi Rayamajhi had received her own share of the family property. Bhaskar Singh Karki still held property that had not been divided. Sarahana’s mother filed a new partition case on her behalf to claim Sarahana’s share in that property.

The case concerned both Sarahana’s share in her father’s property and the question of who should manage that share while she remained a minor.


Plaintiff’s Claim:
Sarahana, through her mother, claimed her legal share in her father’s property. Her mother said that she was Sarahana’s guardian and that the property should remain under her care because Sarahana was living with her. She asked the Court to protect and use the property for Sarahana’s best interests.


Defendant’s Argument:
The father argued that the mother should not control Sarahana’s property. He claimed that the property might be misused if the mother remarried or stopped caring for Sarahana. He also argued that the law placed a child of Sarahana’s age under the father’s responsibility. He asked that the property be placed under his control or under the joint control of both parents.


Legal Issues:

  1. Whether a minor child has the right to claim a share of the father’s property?
  2. Whether the mother could file the case on behalf of her minor daughter?
  3. Whether the mother alone or both parents should be guardians of the minor’s property?
  4. Whether the mother’s possible remarriage was enough to remove her as guardian?


Decision of the Different courts:
Kathmandu District Court:
The District Court held that Sarahana was entitled to her share of the property. It placed the property under her mother’s guardianship. The mother could use the property for Sarahana’s best interests. However, she had to inform the father before transferring or mortgaging it.

Patan High Court:
The High Court partly changed the District Court’s decision. It held that both parents should jointly act as guardians of Sarahana’s property. The property could not be transferred or mortgaged without the consent of both parents.

Supreme Court:
Supreme Court reversed the High Court’s decision and restored the District Court’s order.

The Court held that both parents have the legal right to file cases on behalf of their minor children. Since Sarahana was living with her mother, the mother could also act as the guardian of her property.

The Court clarified that the mother’s possible remarriage was not a valid reason to assume that she would misuse her daughter’s property. Treating her as fit to care for the child but unfit to protect her property would be discriminatory.

The Court also held that the legal provision assigning certain childcare responsibilities to the father did not mean that the father must control the child’s property.

Therefore, the property was to remain under the mother’s guardianship and be used in Sarahana’s best interests. The father had to be informed if the property needed to be transferred or mortgaged, but his consent was not always necessary.

The Supreme Court restored the District Court’s decision.


Principle Established:
1. A minor child has the right to claim a share of parental property, and either parent can file a case on the child’s behalf.
2. A mother can act as the guardian of her child’s property when the child lives under her care.
3. A mother’s possible remarriage or mere suspicion of property misuse cannot be used as a reason to deny her guardianship.
4. The child’s best interests must guide the protection and use of their property.

How did this news make you feel?
0
0
0
0
0
0

About Author

Picture of Entertain Lawyers

Entertain Lawyers

Entertain Lawyers is Nepal’s trusted legal news platform, dedicated to delivering unbiased legal updates, court news, and informative content for legal professionals and the general public.
Picture of Entertain Lawyers

Entertain Lawyers

Entertain Lawyers is Nepal’s trusted legal news platform, dedicated to delivering unbiased legal updates, court news, and informative content for legal professionals and the general public.

Related Post

error: Content is protected !!