Sat 21 November, 2026

Gender and Inclusive Justice Case: Jyoti Paudel vs. Government of Nepal & Others, NKP (7th Semester)

Gender and Inclusive Justice Case: Jyoti Paudel vs. Government of Nepal & Others, NKP (2065), No. 4, P. 485, DN: 8282.


Case:
Mandamus
Plaintiff: Jyoti Paudel
Defendant: Government of Nepal & Others
Decision Number: 8282


This case is relating to domestic violence, acid attacks against women, protection of women’s rights, and the State’s obligations under CEDAW.


Facts of the Case:
The Women Rehabilitation Centre and Advocate Jyoti Paudel filed the petition concerning violence against women, including acid attacks suffered by Sadina Khatun and Rita Devi Mahato.

Sadina Khatun was beaten by her husband while breastfeeding her three year old daughter. He then threw acid at her, which also affected the child. Sadina suffered severe burns and permanent disfigurement to her face and hands. She approached the police, but no effective action was taken.

Rita Devi Mahato was also attacked with acid. She suffered severe burns to her face, neck, and arms. She lost the sight of one eye and was left with permanent injuries and disfigurement. The attack also caused social humiliation and difficulties in her daily life.

The petitioners argued that such violence was linked to social attitudes that treated wives and daughters in law as inferior to men. The existing law did not adequately address serious domestic violence such as acid attacks or provide proper investigation, prosecution, punishment, treatment, compensation, and rehabilitation.


Plaintiff’s Claims:
The petitioners claimed that the State had failed to adequately protect women from domestic violence and discrimination. They argued that Nepal had also failed to properly fulfil its obligations under CEDAW. They asked the Court to order effective laws and systems for investigation, prosecution, punishment, treatment, compensation, rehabilitation, legal assistance, and protection of women victims.


Defendants’ Arguments:
The Home Ministry argued that existing laws applied equally to everyone and that no specific violation of rights had been shown. The Prime Minister’s Office said that the Government was already working to control violence against women and that law making was mainly the legislature’s responsibility. The Ministry of Law argued that acid attacks were already punishable under existing laws. The Ministry of Women, Children and Social Welfare stated that a draft domestic violence law was being considered.


Legal Questions:

  1. Whether the existing law adequately protected women from domestic violence and acid attacks?
  2. Whether Nepal had fulfilled its obligations under CEDAW?
  3. Whether the existing punishment and legal procedures were sufficient for serious domestic violence?
  4. Whether the State should provide victims with effective remedies, including treatment, compensation, legal assistance, rehabilitation, and speedy justice?

 

Different Court Decisions:
Supreme Court:
The Supreme Court held that the case involved both public interest and the rights of the two injured women. It found that existing laws did not adequately protect women from domestic violence and acid attacks.

The Court noted that the Domestic Violence Act did not clearly cover acid attacks. It also lacked proper procedures for investigation, prosecution and evidence collection. The punishment was inadequate for serious forms of violence.

The Court held that Nepal must fulfil its obligations under CEDAW. Under the Nepal Treaty Act, international treaty obligations may prevail over conflicting domestic laws. The State therefore had a duty to provide effective legal protection to women.

The Court directed the Government to broaden the definition of domestic violence, provide effective punishment and establish clear investigation and prosecution procedures. It also ordered free legal assistance for women victims and recommended trained women police officers to investigate such cases.

The Court further directed the Government to consider a separate fast track court for violence against women. It formed a four-member committee to study the required laws, staff, budget and infrastructure.

The Court did not decide the criminal guilt of those responsible for the acid attacks or impose punishment on them.


Principles Established:
1. Domestic violence is a human rights violation, not merely a private family matter. Women must be treated equally and with dignity.
2. Nepal must fulfil its international obligations, including those under CEDAW, and protect women from discrimination.
3. Acid attacks are serious forms of violence that require effective legal protection, investigation, prosecution and punishment.
4. Laws must provide effective remedies for victims, including treatment, compensation, legal assistance, protection and rehabilitation.
5. The State must address discriminatory social practices and ensure speedy and dignified justice, including through special procedures such as fast track courts.
6. Courts may issue directive orders when existing laws and mechanisms fail to protect fundamental rights and international obligations.

How did this news make you feel?
0
0
0
0
0
0

About Author

Picture of Entertain Lawyers

Entertain Lawyers

Entertain Lawyers is Nepal’s trusted legal news platform, dedicated to delivering unbiased legal updates, court news, and informative content for legal professionals and the general public.
Picture of Entertain Lawyers

Entertain Lawyers

Entertain Lawyers is Nepal’s trusted legal news platform, dedicated to delivering unbiased legal updates, court news, and informative content for legal professionals and the general public.

Related Post

error: Content is protected !!